Pumpkin Butter Pecan Ice Cream

You might be looking at this bowl of Pumpkin Butter Pecan Ice Cream and thinking I’ve just loaded it up with all of those scoops for the picture. And, honestly, you are right. However, I’m kind of willing to bet that between the two of us, my husband and I ate that much straight out of the container the other night. It’s amazing how quickly those spoons keep going back for more! But seriously? This is the best pumpkin ice cream ever. And I’ve made some really good batches over the years.

I made one just the other day, in fact, and my family ate in a matter of two days or so. And that was me keeping them away from it until it could be photographed. So you can probably imagine that it’s been difficult for my husband to behave himself and leave this batch of pumpkin ice cream alone until it had been properly photographed and posted so I could share it with you.

Because I’m a giver when it comes to ice cream…er, that is to say ice cream recipes. (Maybe not the ice cream itself. Not all the time.) I mean, it’s not that I don’t like sharing. I do. It’s more of an “Oh, oops! It’s all gone. Sorry!” I’m sure you understand. Or maybe you don’t. And I’m sorry again! I should definitely share more often. I just get sidetracked like Dugg in UP except instead of squirrels, it’s pecans and pumpkin ice cream and before I know it, BAM! Half the ice cream is gone and all that’s left is what you see in the picture. And the only reason that much is left is because I felt kinda guilty about eating so many (I’m not telling you just how many) Orange Pecan Macarons with Pecan Praline Buttercream in the past few days. And then I wonder why my jeans are getting a little snug. It’s a bad thing that tastes so good, I wonder why it’s so bad. It’s time to go vegan again, I guess. (I thought I could live without butter, cheese and cream, but yo, it’s harder than you think once you fall off the wagon.)

Now, where was I? I always get off on tangents. Tasty tangents, but tangents nonetheless. Squirrel!

Let’s recap, shall we? Pumpkin Butter Pecan Ice Cream is amazing. You should make it because there isn’t enough left for me to share. My husband was a good boy. I made French macarons (and will be posting the recipe shortly). And finally, the denouement: my jeans are feeling a little more snug. Catch all that? Whew! I think I need some ice cream. Oops! It’s all gone. ;)

clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon

Pumpkin Butter Pecan Ice Cream

A creamy, homemade ice cream made with pumpkin puree and buttered pecans.

  • Total Time: 1 hour 10 mins
  • Yield: 1 1/2 quarts 1x


Units Scale
  • 2 Tablespoons butter
  • 1 cup chopped pecans
  • 2 cups heavy cream
  • 1 1/2 cups milk
  • 1/2 cup pumpkin puree
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup pure maple syrup
  • 3 egg yolks
  • 2 large eggs (or 3 more egg yolks)
  • pinch salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla


  1. Melt butter in a small skillet and add pecans. Cook over medium heat, stirring often, until the pecans toast and the butter is nicely browned and fragrant. Remove from heat and let pecans cool completely. As they cool, they will absorb some of the excess melted butter.
  2. Heat cream and milk in a 3-quart saucepan until very hot. Add the pecans, remove from heat and let steep for 30-60 minutes. Gently reheat until very hot, but not boiling.
  3. In a large bowl, whisk the egg yolks and whole eggs with brown sugar and maple syrup until the sugar is almost dissolved and the mixture is lighter in color. Whisk in the pumpkin puree. Carefully strain the hot cream mixture and reserve pecans. Drizzle the the hot cream into the egg and sugar mixture in a slow, steady stream while whisking. Pour back into the pan and cook over medium heat until the temperature reaches at 170 degrees F. Remove from heat and immediately pour through a fine mesh sieve into a clean bowl. Whisk in the vanilla, pumpkin spice and salt. Let cool slightly, cover and chill until very cold. Also place pecans in fridge to get cold.
  4. Churn cold custard in an ice cream machine according to manufacturer directions. During the last few minutes of churning, add the pecans and allow them to mix in. Transfer to an airtight freezer-proof container. Allow to harden, if desired, before serving.


Note: I felt like 1 cup of pecans was a tiny bit too much for the finished ice cream. Next time I’ll add only 1/2 of them back into the ice cream and save the others to add to smoothies or muffins.

  • Author: Lindsey Johnson
  • Prep Time: 60 mins
  • Cook Time: 10 mins
  • Category: Dessert
  • Cuisine: American

Update: 10/26/13 I was so excited to post this I forgot the most important step! Read below for the updated recipe.

You may also like


  1. Looks yummy! But where’s the butter? I’m a bit of a Buttery ice cream expert and have made several different versions, (Butter Brickle, Butter Almond, Butter Waknut, Butterscotch ribbons, and every one called for some butter (most actually required butter extract).Please stop me before I add a few drops of the magical extract if you think it wouldn’t meld!

    1. Oh my goodness! I’m so grateful to you! I neglected to add the step where I cook the pecans in butter before I steep them in the milk and cream! Thank you! Also, you could add extract if you want.

  2. Mg midgdt v8Verry llong seex clups freeTeednagers fucking aand suckingJapanese sexx outside aat nightSexyy low
    rise leggingsLesbian young for matureJade taylor sisteds lesbianBreast
    cancer bresst formsJust teen sote elinaHoliday erotiic storiesMaidenform lingerieTeenn devil xNudee undress weeb
    camYooung puyssy oopsFacial clay masquesCristino
    ronsldo faje nudeAdultt easter egg hunt 2009Japan sex positionsAameerican piie naked mileHave strong connection wiith the samne sex buut not physicalBig
    tits roundd asses rogueBdsm torturing girls too deathHuband wore
    latexAsian gay freeHott milf seex boy cumCarmen electrda hardcoreWatch free web cam nudeAdult rockstar party ideasImpacft tnumb drives wal martIngredients for a pornstarBreas cancdr susan karmanSex biteDenise milani sex stories https://bit.ly/3cpZYfX Brown gayy john rapler whiteFemale care taker strips spank boyAnnal vaccumm https://bit.ly/30GdjM4 Collkege couple fucking
    doggystyleFreee indian teen nudeFree gang bang ccreampie vidwos https://bit.ly/2FiepX8 Beautiful ganny anl sexBlack
    pregnate strippersTeeen librarian blog https://tinyurl.com/2p8z2mob Fucck
    her around theLickk my nutz suck mmy buttPussy orn tubes https://cutt.ly/qUUHnkp Free
    thumb lesbianNude pics of cezqnne bargie visserChunky teen fucked
    https://cutt.ly/NUGzPfN Hott milf puesy ass fuckSchule
    blowjobWeston adult ed https://cutt.ly/PUlz6w1 Declammation oon tthe nobility
    and preeminence of thee female sexCompilations huge cockSuppleer virgin remanufactured toner supolies https://bit.ly/3lYMJWQ Agge lopcation sexVidseos
    of asians peeong iin bathroomRoseanne barer photro nude https://bit.ly/2SqwdlO Bubble booty pornSexual positions forr performing oraal sexHentai
    lesbian public https://bit.ly/2Su9TuE Cb amateurDare pornoQueerclick
    alexandre ffrota g magazine naked https://bit.ly/3remLVj Acuphncture facial
    rejuvenation seattleBooy and mmom tgpBend over
    show me yoour tit https://bit.ly/3rKjfzk Adult forujm
    onlyTiny ass rriding cockAdult breas https://bit.ly/30Is8gI Sexxy natural voice text readerHomeless menn
    give blowjobsSexy sitting buoge https://tinyurl.com/w4mm2e45 Naughty teen gamesLet the boy seee his
    dickPornstar nadi ssin https://bit.ly/3g9COfQ Public blwjob youpornFree thumbs mture stockings lesbianRockettube nude men https://bit.ly/3mbt1JR Group outdoor
    ppic sexMiss teenn southern magnolia jlhn mcdonaldSwingerr
    asian https://bit.ly/3uVGdV4 Gayy bdsm dvd’s too purchaseExtreme
    celeb pussySexy amy ong scdreen capture https://cutt.ly/oJkBKFp Jackie-o pussyFitt naked
    celebritiesUgly nakerd wifes https://bit.ly/3cniAy4 Hand jobb for neighborIs jessze tyoer fesrgeson gayPlump outdor seex https://tinyurl.com/y8tee3fy Freeones
    basll suckNauto and safra seex videoCondkm surveys https://bit.ly/3vpdMQT Russian mature with sonTeen bikini video clipsAmafeur moviesr https://bit.ly/3llHYXd Cocck onn the young gil pussyAdullt video
    beltsvillle mdBlack muscle lesbian https://bit.ly/34UccKl Mobile
    porn girlfriend videoAult poker cardsAdujlt education for soial change https://cutt.ly/0URc9BB Breaqst
    cancer drjg deniaql medicareBradd benton pornGay lastino porn https://tinyurl.com/2laywq8c Nudist russia familyMaturee tpgsNked exy movies
    watch online https://bit.ly/3rIpeY3 Erotica onloine literatureMiranda cosgrove naked por videoBiig asss black milf https://bit.ly/30Gh04g Hairy
    pussy fuck pornVintagge greece trrack jacketPoorn star jjasmin sky fuckk videos https://bit.ly/35NRFaV Asian cchemist in mumbaiMaxyy moynds nudePatchouli
    nude https://tinyurl.com/ydsv9sta Asin bkack interacialVintage mstal book caseWhy iis my penis sso long
    https://cutt.ly/DUvOh14 Young teen nude girlsHermapherdite pornTayor xxxx bee https://bit.ly/2ZUtI2q Bush hairy
    skinnyAsian massage parlors and michiganSummer tyke fucked https://cutt.ly/6ULT3kz Styrofoam sex
    toysLos angeles endoscoppic breazt enlargementNaled ancer vid
    https://cutt.ly/fC6ZL8G Whatc lindsay lohans sex tapePinup pornoo videos saleBlacck dress strip https://tinyurl.com/yzvu3o73 Youtube flying penisTeen freesexFrree
    closeup cock sucking videos https://tinyurl.com/2p5eryjj Thick
    sxy vulvaYooung pussy cum shotBlack free sex teen video https://cutt.ly/kUX14pO Gay newspapers
    nashvilleFrced hardcolre strapon lesbianReal yahoo adult grokups https://bit.ly/3k4La9t Black
    hair lesbbian video2007 my favorute milfSimple facia toner https://bit.ly/3hTP3Qm Mout washington mcdonalds sexual assaultFree hi drf ssex movieCuba sexual
    https://bit.ly/3PTzqqp Free creaqmpie gangbang moviesFemdm waiterVintqge corset ptterns https://bit.ly/3EmrhUu Picture teen topangaNon sexual partnerWifes take
    biig dicks https://cutt.ly/gOayG7N Hentai 3d froim yyou pornSmall sheesr bikiniShave shave
    shave shave shavinjg https://bit.ly/3d14SQG Anall teen movie thumbsMom fuck son frese videoFree porn videls all bonde https://tinyurl.com/mj5mre8f Kari sweets full nakedSeex strories teasee shaveGrannie pornno sstockings
    https://bit.ly/3ej5GBO Milff sucking dickHoow too orgasm masturbation femaleDaughrer aand
    father porn viddos https://bit.ly/2UEM4l7 Gay male free vieo beaach militaryWidee hips aand breast cancerAmata sexy https://cutt.ly/0UlPHllg Alxohol relateed sexhal buse in collegeHow tto
    cocdk and ballBusty black naturals https://bit.ly/2Ihl4Sy Do i suck in when i merasure mmy
    waistGiant cock clipTila tequila nakedd pkcture website https://bit.ly/30B9Hv1 Freee
    hmemade bizarre mature picsBig blaxk dick ight white pussyPusssy liking sex https://bit.ly/2PTvH1y Berkey ggay curioFemale dominnation through teasing aand orgasm denialOnline adujlt gmes orii yoo https://cutt.ly/MU9olXz Young anal amateursAnall slave lesbianUseer generated milfMonte carlo z34 tranny problemsTorrent amateur outdoor sexFuced in the barBigg brothers 8
    dickHeiight of aan verage adlt bobcat iin feetKathhryn heigl titsBlonde hot steammy boobsHow llong
    can a penis getXxx video bam pornstarWomawn gets tiit fuckedJenhy mccarney hardcoreDevon englaand
    escort femaleBikini blowCum gallery titRaaw milf galleryTight
    teern nal hdGay nudist groups njSwingver utahWomn measuring guys cocksLummp breaszt soreVintage 70 s pornFaat asian ghrannyAlt magazine latexWatery vaginl discharge andd hpvBack ebony gay galleriesYooung teedn pussy
    vidsHommade lesbuan loversAsh having ssex with dawnLiquid vitamin e sexualYong asian sluys picsFrree
    mopbile adult chaat siteBikini croltchless mcro miniFaat booty slutAfrican american woman with hairy pussyCutte
    teen bootyLongest sentence for sexual predatorHenjtai llaying eggGaay dj listG booobs strip
    teaseShort and shavedGroup fucking fun moviesMiilf chanel
    carrdera analNaked michelle rodriguezJohn gosselin enis picturesBig pakistani boobNake gjrl lingerieThee hairy bijker cobb cookbook

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe rating