This recipe is actually a bit of an update to one of my older recipes from 2006. I decided it was time for a little facelift and so I left out the cream cheese and made this ice cream taste more like Key Lime Pie and less like cheesecake. A good move, I think, though my hubby said he actually missed the cream cheese a little bit. In any case, Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is pretty great and it’s something that you’ll start to crave.A little scoop of ice cream topped with crumbled ginger cookies (Trader Joe’s gluten-free, of course) is the perfect dessert when you’re ready to kick back, open the windows and watch the latest episode of your favorite TV show. We did just that as a family and had a great time. I can’t remember for the life of me what we watched–and it was just a few days ago. But I do remember looking at my little people and being happy to have them around for a few more hours a day.
Key Lime Pie Ice Cream
A homemade ice cream that tastes just like key lime pie – complete with cookie crumbs!
- Total Time: 30 mins
- Yield: 1 quart 1x
Ingredients
- 14 ounce can sweetened condensed milk
- 1 cup heavy cream
- 1 1/2 cups whole milk
- 2–3 teaspoons finely grated lime zest (optional)
- 3/4 cup fresh key lime juice
- 4 large egg yolks
- 1/2 cup evaporated cane juice (or granulated sugar)
- pinch salt
- For garnish:
- crumbled graham or shortbread cookies, for sprinkling (I used gluten-free gingersnaps)
- cones or bowls, for serving
Instructions
- Whisk together sweetened condensed milk, cream, milk, and lime zest in a 3-quart sauce pan. Heat over medium, being careful not to let it boil, until very hot to the touch. Remove from heat.
- In a large mixing bowl whisk egg yolks with sugar and pinch of salt until thick and lighter in color. Slowly drizzle the hot milk and cream mixture into the yolks, whisking constantly. When all of the hot milk mixture has been added, return the mixture to the pan and cook gently over medium heat until an instant read thermometer reaches at least 160°to 170°F, but no more than 180 degrees, or the custard will curdle. Remove from heat and pour through a fine mesh sieve. Stir in the fresh key lime juice. Cover and let chill until very cold.
- Churn in ice cream maker according to manufacturer’s directions. Transfer churned ice cream to an airtight, freezer-safe container. Freeze until firm enough to scoop. Will keep for up to a month in the freezer. To prevent frost from forming on the surface, press a piece of waxed or parchment paper against the top before putting the lid on the container.
- Prep Time: 20 mins
- Cook Time: 10 mins
*Need help making ice cream from scratch? You might want to check out my Homemade Ice Cream 101 post.
Here are some of my other recipes using Key limes:
Frozen Coconut Key Lime Tart
Creamy Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Candied Ginger Ice Cream
Key Lime Tart
Creamy Key Lime Pie Ice Cream
Florida Pie
180 Comments
Your ice cream looks and sounds absolutely divine!
I love custard based ice creams. And Key Lime is my FAV!!!!
My husband is a huge key lime fan. We’ll have to try this!
I’m trying this recipe! It looks delish.
Hey — I was driving home tonight from our RS social and was thinking about you. I hope you’re doing well and summer has been fun so far.
ep
I’ve never made a key lime ice cream, but when I do it will be your recipe.
Love those dishes!
Can you still make this if you don’t have a ice-cream maker? Thank you in advance for your reply. -Donna Perales
You sure can! Combine everything and freeze it in a bowl or pan. Every 30-60 minutes, give it a good whisking and place it back in the freezer. When it’s really thick like soft serve ice cream, stop the whisking and just let it finish freezing until it’s firm enough to scoop.
I want to send this to my daughter. We all love key lime pie or anything with them in it.
You mention lime zest in your recipe but it’s not in the list of ingredients. How much should be used?
Hi Mike! Thanks for alerting me to that typo. I actually took the opportunity to proofread this again (it’s been a long time!) and fix other typos and clarify things in the directions. I now prefer to add the zest early on in the recipe rather than the end and strain it to remove the little bits. I like the texture better. But feel free to add it in along with the lime juice if you don’t mind the zest in the final product. Let me know how you like it! This is definitely still a family favorite at my house. :)
I am thankful for you and your generosity.
I’d love for you to feel the gratitude I’m feeling at the moment.
You’re the most excellent.
I’m not sure what I’d do without you, and I’d like never to find out!
You deserve to be acknowledged for the kindness you’ve shown to me.
Your blog was a beauty, and I am grateful to you for sharing it.
It’s a blessing being surrounded by someone as you, and who is always there to help others.
I am truly grateful for your support in this endeavor.
“Thank you” does not feel enough, but it’s my feelings. I’m grateful for the job you’ve put into it.
Do you have no limit in your generous spirit?
Sincere gratitude.
Your article was refreshing and refreshing I am grateful for it!
antihistamine generic names do you need a prescription allergy medications for itching skin
https://laf.clubdeinversionistas.com/hindi/charmsukh-chawl-house-2-ullu-2022-hindi-hot-web-series-ep-2/ – HD 43K 22:04 91% Charmsukh Chawl House 2 Ullu 2022 Hindi Hot Web Series Ep 2
http://marketingdigitallocal.com/videos/59570/546erofc-111-20-sex-h/ – HD [546EROFC-111] ???????????????20? ??????????????????????????????SEX????H??????????… 50:40 100% 3 months ago 10K
http://f.spiritualspectrum.com/tag/568/ – des vid?os porno gratuit
http://gzfi.powercontinuitysolutions.co.uk/videos/little-kitty – Little Kitty
https://aluxide.us/category/stormy-daniels/ – Stormy Daniels
sleeping prescription sleeping pills online cheap modafinil 200mg
purchase deltasone order generic prednisone 40mg
how to relief heartburn quinapril where to buy
“Thank you” isn’t enough, but it’s what I feel. I am truly thankful for the work you’ve put into it.
will pimple get wase when taking fulcin buy prednisone 40mg generic acne treatments for teen girls
allergy pills prescribed by doctors buy generic claritin 10mg prescription allergy medicine list
tablet for abdominal pain buy trimethoprim generic
buy generic isotretinoin online cheap accutane 20mg order accutane 10mg
sleeping pills order online buy provigil without a prescription
order amoxicillin 500mg amoxicillin canada amoxil 500mg for sale
buy zithromax 500mg sale zithromax 500mg over the counter zithromax uk
buy gabapentin 800mg neurontin cost
buy azipro no prescription azipro 250mg ca azithromycin 250mg tablet
lasix ca buy generic lasix for sale
prednisolone 20mg cheap buy generic prednisolone purchase omnacortil online
I admire your thought process and actions. It’s not often that I get to experience the kind of generosity you show.
Your thoughtfulness and kindness are not going in silence. I will remember it throughout my life.
You’ve been incredibly supportive throughout this challenging period. I would not get to the end without your help.
What can we do to thank you enough for all the good you’ve done? We’re forever grateful.
prednisone price prednisone 5mg uk
Thank you for the useful ideas and strategies that you offered.
Your gesture will mean a lot to me.
order amoxicillin 500mg pill amoxil 250mg generic order generic amoxil
order acticlate pill order vibra-tabs
My heart and my soul will always be thankful to you. I am grateful to you. awe-inspiring.
The most kind people I’ve had the pleasure of meeting.
My heart and soul will always be thankful to you. I am grateful to you. awe-inspiring.
Thanks for helping to make difficult topics understandable.
This is really thoughtful of you!
My heart and soul will always be thankful to you. Thanks for always being so amazing.
In addition to “thanks,” I hope that you feel my appreciation as well as my appreciation over an extended period of time.
I’d like to invite you to experience the joy I’m feeling right now.
I’m grateful for the useful suggestions you’ve given us.
We thank you so much for becoming an illuminator of wisdom and knowledge.
I am grateful for the passion you convey in your writing. Thank you!
order albuterol order albuterol inhalator sale buy generic albuterol
augmentin 1000mg sale how to buy augmentin
order synthroid 100mcg generic order generic levothroid synthroid 100mcg cheap
order levitra 20mg without prescription order levitra 20mg without prescription
buy clomid 50mg sale serophene over the counter clomid 100mg without prescription
rybelsus where to buy oral semaglutide semaglutide 14mg generic
Hello, i think that i saw you visited my blog
thus i got here to return the desire?.I’m trying to find issues to enhance my site!I guess its adequate to make use of some of your ideas!!
https://infinitara.top
★★★★★
buy rybelsus 14mg online rybelsus 14mg us buy generic semaglutide online
buy prednisone 20mg generic deltasone 20mg drug prednisone drug
accutane price accutane cost buy accutane online
order generic albuterol purchase ventolin for sale purchase albuterol inhaler
buy amoxicillin tablets order amoxicillin for sale amoxicillin 1000mg without prescription
augmentin 375mg us order augmentin 1000mg without prescription brand clavulanate
purchase azithromycin generic order zithromax 250mg pill buy zithromax 500mg online cheap
I want to to thank you for this fantastic read!!
I absolutely loved every little bit of it. I have you saved as a
favorite to check out new things you post… I saw similar here: sklep and also here: najlepszy sklep
★★★★★
levoxyl canada buy generic levothyroxine over the counter order synthroid 75mcg online
order generic omnacortil prednisolone 40mg sale how to get omnacortil without a prescription
buy generic clomid 50mg order serophene sale clomiphene 50mg brand
cheap neurontin 800mg oral gabapentin buy neurontin 100mg online cheap
order lasix 100mg online cheap buy furosemide pills diuretic order furosemide generic
sildenafil 100 mg buy generic viagra 50mg order viagra 100mg generic
Thank you for sharing your info. I really appreciate your efforts and I am
waiting for your further write ups thanks once again.
I saw similar here: dobry sklep and also here: sklep online
★★★★★
semaglutide canada semaglutide oral rybelsus cheap
Your mode of describing everything in this article is really good, every one can effortlessly know it, Thanks a lot.
I saw similar here: e-commerce and also here:
sklep internetowy
★★★★★
A fascinating discussion is definitely worth comment.
There’s no doubt that that you need to publish more about this subject matter, it might not be a taboo subject but usually
folks don’t discuss these issues. To the next! Cheers!!!
★★★★★
free slot games for fun free casino vegas casino online
vardenafil 20mg drug order levitra 10mg pill brand vardenafil 20mg
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.info/join?ref=WTOZ531Y
buy lyrica 75mg sale lyrica without prescription lyrica order
zithromax suspension dosing
My brother recommended I might like this web site.
He was totally right. This post truly made my day.
You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this info!
Thanks! I saw similar here: dobry sklep and also here:
ecommerce
★★★★★
order hydroxychloroquine without prescription hydroxychloroquine 400mg cost brand plaquenil 200mg
oral aristocort 4mg buy triamcinolone 10mg generic triamcinolone for sale online
order cialis 10mg for sale cialis 40mg tablet order tadalafil 40mg online cheap
online pharmacy usa cialis from canada pharmacy
canadian pharmacies for viagra [url=http://canadianphrmacy23.com/]check here[/url]
buy cenforce 50mg sale order cenforce 50mg pill buy generic cenforce for sale
alternative to metformin
order loratadine 10mg buy loratadine sale claritin buy online
buy chloroquine tablets chloroquine generic buy chloroquine 250mg for sale
buy generic glucophage online buy glucophage paypal order metformin 1000mg online
over the counter substitute for furosemide
zoloft and ibuprofen
metronidazole same as flagyl
lisinopril and african american
buy amlodipine pills order norvasc 10mg pill buy amlodipine cheap
buy zovirax 400mg pill zyloprim online buy zyloprim oral
how to make lasix work better
lijek glucophage
canadian cialis online pharmacy Canadian Pharmacy ONLINE to Usa
canadian pharmacy cialis [url=http://canadianphrmacy23.com/]Check This Out[/url]
zithromax pregnancy safe
gabapentin in cats
buy cheap zestril buy zestril 10mg for sale zestril usa
where to buy crestor without a prescription buy rosuvastatin medication buy zetia online cheap
Wow, marvelous blog structure! How lengthy have you
been blogging for? you made running a blog glance easy.
The total glance of your web site is fantastic, let alone the content material!
You can see similar: sklep online
and here sklep online
★★★★★
500mg amoxicillin
gabapentin dogs
how to buy prilosec buy prilosec generic buy prilosec generic
domperidone price sumycin buy online tetracycline brand
cephalexin vs keflex
escitalopram and sleep
It’s very interesting! If you need help, look here: hitman agency
flexeril 15mg for sale order generic baclofen 10mg baclofen 10mg pill
ciprofloxacin and tylenol
bactrim sirve para la garganta
bactrim ds dose for adults
toradol 10mg canada gloperba without prescription buy cheap colchicine
what is cephalexin
atenolol 100mg generic buy tenormin without a prescription cheap tenormin 100mg
cost of medrol methylprednisolone brand name buy medrol uk
Ridiculous story there. What occurred after? Thanks! I saw similar here: sklep internetowy and
also here: ecommerce
★★★★★
buy inderal 10mg clopidogrel 75mg sale clopidogrel 75mg pills
pay to do assignment order research papers my childhood essay writing
does amoxicillin expire
order methotrexate 10mg generic purchase medex pill order warfarin 5mg online
purchase meloxicam pill mobic 7.5mg us celecoxib pill
can cephalexin treat tooth infection
buy generic maxolon over the counter cozaar generic purchase hyzaar pills
gabapentin for anxiety dose
tamsulosin generic order celecoxib sale order celebrex 200mg generic
escitalopram dosage 40 mg
The author’s expertise and attention to detail were truly impressive. I felt truly informed after reading this. | Tuzla Loveseat Yıkama
buy esomeprazole 40mg generic order topamax online topiramate over the counter
The author’s deep interest and knowledge were truly impressive. The inclusion of examples and case studies made the topic even more enlightening. | Soğanlık Yeni, Kartal Battaniye Yıkama
buy ondansetron 8mg generic zofran order order generic spironolactone 100mg
buy generic sumatriptan over the counter buy generic imitrex levofloxacin cost
Adıyaman Prefabrik Yapı | We were highly satisfied with the service provided. They meet expectations both in terms of product quality and customer service.
is citalopram a narcotic
Hayrabolu Jakuzi Modelleri | Atlas Jakuzi’nin ürünleri gerçekten şaşırtıcı! Konfor ve lüksü bir araya getiriyorlar.
simvastatin 20mg drug purchase zocor without prescription buy generic valacyclovir 1000mg
Eğil, Diyarbakır Jakuzi | Atlas Jakuzi’nin ürünleriyle her gün biraz lüks yaşamak mümkün. Bu yazı, bu deneyimi daha yakından tanımama yardımcı oldu.
buy generic dutasteride for sale order avodart 0.5mg sale ranitidine 150mg oral
cozaar and grapefruit
buy ddavp no prescription
purchase propecia buy cheap finasteride cost fluconazole 200mg
100. Yıl Karotcu | Rüzgar Karot’un hızlı geri dönüşleri ve çözüm odaklı yaklaşımı beni çok etkiledi.
Kayseri Web Tasarım | MAFA’s content on web design feels like a secret treasure trove of knowledge waiting to be discovered.
depakote side effects elderly
Mimar Sinan Mahallesi, Dilovası Çekyat Yıkama | PENTA’nın çözümleri, işletmemizin hijyen standartlarını artırmak için harika bir seçenek gibi görünüyor. Teşekkürler!
Hurrah, that’s what I was looking for, what a information!
present here at this website, thanks admin of
this website. I saw similar here: Sklep online
★★★★★
buy acillin without a prescription buy acillin for sale order amoxil for sale
İslambey / Eyüp Karot | Rüzgar Karot’un sunduğu hizmetten çok memnun kaldım, herkese gönül rahatlığıyla tavsiye ederim.
Küçükçekmece Plastik Bardak | Eminoğlu Packaging offers both eco-friendly and quality packaging solutions. That’s why we prefer them!
cipro order – order cephalexin online amoxiclav pills
order ciprofloxacin online cheap – buy septra online augmentin 375mg cost
Joomla Sitenizi Offline Konuma Alma | MAFA’nın içerikleri, web tasarımı ve yazılım dünyasındaki karmaşık konuları anlamama yardımcı oluyor. Bu değerli bilgileri bizimle paylaştığınız için teşekkür ederim.
SEA Friesland | Deze blog is echt informatief! MAFA’s expertise op het gebied van webdesign en softwareontwikkeling is werkelijk indrukwekkend.
citalopram long term side effects
İnönü, Gebze Çekyat Yıkama | PENTA’nın yıkama çözümleriyle ilgili bu yazı, işletmemin temizlik ve hijyen konusundaki ihtiyaçlarını nasıl karşılayabileceğimi daha iyi anlamama yardımcı oldu. Harika bir kaynak!
cozaar mg
Kartepe Plise Perde Çeşitleri | Venster Systems’ retractable insect screens are a product I’ve recommended to my friends with children, offering peace of mind.
uremia ddavp
depakote classification
Cevizlik Beton Delme | I’m very satisfied with the service provided by Rüzgar Karot, providing quality and trust at every stage.
order metronidazole generic – buy cefaclor 500mg generic order azithromycin 500mg sale
Yenikent Mahallesi, Gebze Çekyat Yıkama | PENTA’nın çözümleri, işletmemizin hijyen standartlarını artırmak için harika bir seçenek gibi görünüyor. Teşekkürler!
order ciplox 500mg – order erythromycin 250mg without prescription order erythromycin sale
Venster Systems’ blinds have exceeded my expectations in terms of both aesthetics and functionality. | Kütahya Plise Perde Sistemleri
ezetimibe monotherapy clinical trials
drinking on augmentin